← Blog

· Updated

Which of Europe's big five leagues is the most homegrown?

La Liga is 61.8 percent Spanish and the Premier League 32.4 percent English, but Serie A is barely ahead of England, and Lecce register four Italians in a squad of 34. Nationality across 2,897 squad entries.

Every summer somebody announces that there is no room left for English players in the Premier League. Every summer somebody else points at Spain and says that is how it should be done. Both arguments usually run on one or two famous clubs and a feeling.

We counted instead. Every player registered for 2026-27 by the clubs of the Premier League, La Liga, the Bundesliga, Serie A and Ligue 1, from the leagues' own squad lists: 2,897 entries, each with the nationality the league records. The lists include academy players with first-team numbers, and a player carries one sporting nationality even if he holds two passports, so these are entries measured against a single flag.

Which league has the most home players?

League Entries Home share Nationalities Clubs with a home majority
La Liga 595 61.8% Spanish 68 17 of 20
Bundesliga 541 50.5% German 64 8 of 18
Ligue 1 526 42.0% French 69 3 of 18
Serie A 634 34.4% Italian 70 1 of 20
Premier League 601 32.4% English 63 1 of 20

The headline survives. The Premier League is the least homegrown of the five. What does not survive is the idea that it is out on its own. Serie A sits two points behind it, with more nationalities than any league here, and almost nobody writes the same summer column about Italy.

Is the Premier League really the most foreign?

Only if a Welshman is a foreigner.

There are 195 English players among the Premier League's 601 entries. Everton are the only club with an English majority, 14 of 25, or 56.0 percent. At the other end Brighton register five Englishmen in a squad of 34, 14.7 percent, spread across 24 nationalities. Brentford are on 17.2 percent.

Add the rest of the British Isles, 14 Welsh, 10 Scottish, 10 Irish and eight Northern Irish players, and the figure becomes 237 of 601, or 39.4 percent. On that count the Premier League is more homegrown than Serie A and close behind Ligue 1. Whether it is the most cosmopolitan league in Europe depends almost entirely on where you draw a border that football itself draws in four places.

Serie A, the cosmopolitan league nobody mentions

Serie A registers 70 nationalities, the most of the five. Frosinone are its only club with an Italian majority, 16 of 30.

Lecce are the extreme case in all five leagues. Their squad of 34 contains four Italians, Wladimiro Falcone, Marco Bleve, Antonino Gallo and Christian Lupo, and 26 nationalities, more than any other club in the data. Udinese have five Italians among 28 players, and they and Sassuolo field 21 nationalities each.

The finding that should sting in Italy is where the Italians are not. This is the country whose football reputation was built on defending, and Italians fill 63 of Serie A's 210 defender places, 30.0 percent. Spain supply 12 more, Brazil 11 and France 10. Italian goalkeepers have held on better, 48 of 81, or 59.3 percent.

When Italy does export, it exports defenders. Only 27 Italian entries play in the other four leagues, and 17 of them are defenders: Riccardo Calafiori at Arsenal, Destiny Udogie at Tottenham, Giovanni Leoni at Liverpool among them. Twelve of the 27 are in England. The back-line tradition is alive. It is just increasingly being exercised abroad.

Why is La Liga so Spanish?

Seventeen of its twenty clubs have a Spanish majority. The most Spanish is not Athletic Bilbao, whose recruitment from the Basque Country is the most famous policy in Spanish football. It is Málaga, with 26 Spaniards out of 30 and only four nationalities in the squad. Athletic are second on 24 of 29, 82.8 percent, with Osasuna close behind on 23 of 28.

The least Spanish club is Real Madrid, 12 of 33, or 36.4 percent. Villarreal are next on 40.7. Yet Real Madrid, La Liga's most international squad, is more Spanish than twelve Premier League clubs are English.

The simplest explanation is supply. Spain is the biggest producer of top-flight footballers in this data, with 426 entries across the five leagues, and it keeps them. Only 58 Spaniards, 13.6 percent, play in one of the other four. A league with that much domestic talent on its doorstep does not need to look far.

Where does the Bundesliga sit?

Almost exactly in the middle, 50.5 percent German, and with the widest spread between its clubs. Paderborn register 30 Germans in a squad of 33, 90.9 percent, the most homegrown club in all five leagues, alongside just three other nationalities. Elversberg are next in Germany on 74.1 percent.

Two of its best-known clubs sit at the other end. Borussia Dortmund are 30.0 percent German, 9 of 30, and Bayer Leverkusen 31.0 percent. The Bundesliga's biggest foreign contingents come from France, with 30 players, Austria with 21 and Japan with 14.

Germans, like Spaniards and Italians, mostly stay at home. Of 307 German entries, 34 play elsewhere in the big five, 11.1 percent. The Italian rate is 11.0 and the English 16.7. The outlier is France, where 116 of 337 players, 34.4 percent, are registered outside Ligue 1, which is a story of its own and the reason Ligue 1 has the most African players of any big five league.

Which position is the most homegrown?

Goalkeeper, and it is not close. Across the five leagues, 202 of 349 goalkeepers play in their own country's league, 57.9 percent. For outfield players the figure is 1,073 of 2,548, or 42.1 percent.

League Home goalkeepers Home outfield players
Bundesliga 79.7% 46.5%
La Liga 62.1% 61.8%
Serie A 59.3% 30.7%
Ligue 1 49.2% 41.0%
Premier League 41.1% 31.3%

Part of that is the shape of a squad. A club carries three or four keepers and plays one, and the spare places are the cheapest to fill from your own academy or your own league. So the fair test is the No. 1 shirt, which usually goes to the first choice.

On that test the Bundesliga still stands out. Thirteen of its 18 No. 1 shirts belong to Germans, from Manuel Neuer at Bayern to Oliver Baumann at Hoffenheim and Noah Atubolu at Eintracht Frankfurt. In the Premier League, 16 clubs issue a No. 1 and six give it to an Englishman: Jordan Pickford, Nick Pope, Dean Henderson, Jack Butland, Alex Palmer and James Trafford. Germany's goalkeeping production line, which shows up in our study of which countries produce which positions, is not a myth kept alive by back-ups.

So who is doing it right?

Nobody, in the sense the summer columns mean. La Liga is homegrown because Spain produces more footballers than it can export. The Premier League is foreign because it can afford anyone, and its home nations are counted four ways. Serie A has quietly become nearly as international as England while its defenders leave for London and Liverpool.

The Champions League nationalities breakdown shows the same forces at European level, where some countries reach two dozen clubs and some reach one. And if you play the Serie A puzzle, keep the Lecce squad in mind: a mystery player in Italy is, two times out of three, not Italian.